TiVo edge vs TiVo Roamio

Are you looking for a serviceable DVR, with a modern interface, streaming convenience and comes at an affordable price? Find a convenient DVR for you in this TiVo edge vs TiVo Roamio comparison.

From the late 90’s TiVo has changed the way people view television. The company paved way for many DVR companies today. For a long time, TiVo was a common household name. While they are not as popular as they were back then, TiVo continues to introduce new, desirable DVRs to the market. TiVo’s edge may not be the newest DVR in the market, but its quiet noticeable. It packs a number of features, combining popular streaming apps with television.  This guide takes a look at how the TiVo edge compares to a slightly older OTA DVR version, the TiVo Roamio.  What are the differences between the two, and which one is a better model for a modern home? Find out below.

What are the differences between TiVo edge and TiVo Roamio

Model
TiVo edge
TiVo Roamio
Dimensions
1.8 by 11.4 by 7.3 inches.
7.4 x 14.2 x 2 inches
Ports
2xUSB + 1xHDMI 2.0
2xUSB + 1xHDMI
Storage
3TB, 1TB, 500GB
1TB
Recording capacity
300HD hours
1000SD hours
Tuners
4- 6
4

TiVo bolt vs TiVo edge – how do they compare?

Design

The TiVo edge looks like two rectangular, flat plastic boxes stacked together. The top box is, however, pushed slightly more outwards to the back and the right of the bottom box. The TiVo edge weights 1.9 pounds and measures 1.8 by 11.4 by 7.3 inches.

On the front of bottom section is the TiVo logo located at the centre and indicator lights at the far right. The back of the TiVo edge has an Ethernet port, HDMI output, an antenna connector, an optical audio output, two USB 3.0 ports, a remote finder button and a power port.

TiVo Roamio is a bulky DVR and looks more like a cable ox than a basic/modern streaming device.  The DVR weighs an outstanding 3.7 pounds with a measurement of 7.4 x 14.2 x 2 inches. At the back of the DVRs is a HDMI output port, some USB port to charge other devices, and an optical audio jack to connect to sound systems.

The TiVo edge DVR has a more compact and manageable design when compared to the TiVo Roamio OTA DVR

Remote

The TiVo edge comes with a standard, dog bone shaped chunky black remote. The remote also has a number pad, channel and volume rockers, thumbs up and down buttons, 4 colored letter buttons, a dedicated Netflix button and other menu controls.

The playback control pad sits at the centre of the remote, with the   skip, play, forward and backward arranged around the pause button. Near the top of the remote is a small circular navigation pad. There is also a microphone that allows you to use edge’s voice search feature. All one needs to do is speak into the pinhole microphone located below the Home button.

The TiVo Roamio remote has an old school design to it. The directional buttons and standard numerical keypad is responsible for that. The remote comes with a full media control suite that includes thumbs up and thumbs down features, skip, play and pause features , list and enter buttons plus more.

The TiVo edge has a more advanced, modern remote when compared o that of the TiVo Roamio.

Subscription

The TiVo edge for antenna will require you to pay $6.99 per month, 69.99 per year or a lifetime subscription of $249.99. Its cable subscription is a bit more expensive, you will need to pay $14.99 per month, $149.99 per year or a lifetime subscription of $549.99. The subscription includes full channel guide support and show information for every episode.

The TiVo Roamio on the other hand does not require a subscription.

The TiVo edge subscription is much more expensive than the TiVo Roamio, which does not require a subscription.

TiVo Roamio vs TiVo edge – A comparison overview

TiVo Roamio OTA Overview

TiVo Roamio OTA 1 TB DVR - With No Monthly Service Fees - Digital Video Recorder and Streaming Media Player
  • Compatible only with HDTV Antennas. Does not work with cable or satellite TV. No monthly TiVo service fee...
  • Record four shows at once and up to 150 hours of HD programming. Pause, rewind and record free HD...

If you are looking to ditch cable but still enjoy cable experience, the TiVo Roamio DVR is the perfect choice for you.  The TiVo Roamio OTA DVR provides you with the comfort of a cable box; limitless recording, traditional channel grid and a button packed remote control for users to enjoy.

The TiVo Roamio comes with 1TB of internal hard drive storage. With this DVR, you can record up to 1000 hours of SD content. The TiVo Roamio has 4 tuners which allow users to records multiple shows simultaneously. You can stream to multiple locations or rooms in your home. You can skip commercials and schedule recordings on the TiVo Roamio.

For users with children, the DVR has parental control features that lets you adjust access control. Unlike other TiVo DVRs, this one does not require a subscription. However, the DVR does limit access and recording to over the air content.

Pros

  • Does not require subscription
  • Smooth video and audio quality
  • Great recommendation services
  • Great search features

Cons

  • Has a miserable set up
  • The device is bulky
  • Does not work with cable or satellite TV

View Price on Amazon

TiVo edge Overview

TiVo Edge for Cable | Cable TV, DVR and Streaming 4K UHD Media Player with Dolby Vision HDR and Dolby Atmos
  • Maximize your TV potential! TiVo EDGE for cable brings all your cable TV channels, recordings and top...
  • As powerful inside as it is streamlined and sleek on the outside. Schedule and record up to 6 cable shows...

For TV users looking for a far more convenient and practical DVR, the TiVo edge might just be the one for you. Its rectangular, double stacked design makes it easy to stack among other boxes or next to your TV, unlike other older DVR designs.  The DVR has a glossy coating, giving it a smooth glossy appearance and reflects lights from your entertainment system

There is not much change in its remotes design.  The remote is thick, has enough buttons and fits comfortably in ones hand. It also features back lit keys that create a nice glow during night time.  Setting up the TiVo edge box Is easy and straightforward.

Unlike older models, the TiVo edge has packed streaming apps. You get access to more streaming services with this DVR. Users have access to Hulu, prime video, Netflix, Pandora, HBO go, YouTube, and more. The DVR has 6 tuners, which allow users to record up to 6 TV shows or movies simultaneously. The model also includes mobile app support which you can use to view and manage content. OTHER additional features include Ethernet connectivity, HDR content support, optical audio support and a cableCARD slot.

Pros

  • The flat design enables quieter processor
  • Has plenty of streaming options
  • The set up is simple
  • Has a roust voice remote

Cons

  • Overall expensive to maintain
  • Streaming apps are limited in comparison to other DVRs
  • The mirror finish on the DVR can cause light glares

View Price on Amazon

Verdict: So, which one is better – TiVo Roamio or TiVo edge?

TiVo edge takes the win in this comparison.  Although the TiVo Roamio is limited to over the air content, it is a solid DVR with good video and audio streaming services.  However, the TiVo edge is a much better DVR, giving users the ability to watch more than over the air content. With the edge, you can stream shows from website like Netflix and Hulu and also access a ton of features on the DVR.

FAQ

Can I stream from Roamio to TiVo EDGE on the same network?

Yes you can, as long as they are both on the same TiVo account

Does TiVo Roamio OTA require subscription?

Unlike other TiVo, this old DVR model does not require a subscription for over the air program access.

Leave a Comment