Powerline vs. Ethernet – Which form of networking is the best?
Interested in determining the difference between Powerline and Ethernet? Then you have come to the right place. Read on for the extensive review and comparison of both Ethernet and Powerline.
Many users often prefer wireless internet connections over the wired counterparts. This is often because wireless connections eliminate the need for physical connecting cables. However, access over different ranges is a major problem with wireless connection. Some part of your space may not access connection, leaving you with internet dead zones within your space.
Ethernet and Powerline are both wonderful networking solutions which help connect devices as needed. Both are set up and operate quite differently. If you are interested in either Powerline or Ethernet networking solutions: how each form of networking operates, what it features, major requirements and differences, then take a look at Powerline vs. Ethernet for more.
Table of Contents
What are the differences between Powerline vs. Ethernet?
Powerline (Winner) |
Ethernet |
|
Transmission Medium |
Electrical wiring system |
Ethernet cable |
Range |
Limited to one network |
10km range |
System |
Wired |
Wired |
Delivery rates |
Varies with type of adapter |
Fast reliable delivery |
Powerline vs. Ethernet – What are the main differences between the two?
Reliability
One notable difference between Ethernet and Powerline connections is the reliability of said connection. The primary Powerline network depends on electrical impulses sent over wiring and is susceptible to electrical interference. In fact, these connection is subject to fluctuation is performance due to electrical noise among other factors. Ethernet networks are directly connected to the router/connection source, with minimal instances of interference.
Speed and performance
While both Powerline and Ethernet networks are built on dependable speeds, you cannot compare the performance and transfer speeds. Evidently, Ethernet networks offer faster connections whose speed and performance is
Unfortunately, connection over Powerline, the speed and performance specifically, is not exactly what it is marketed out to be. In fact, outside the ideal scenarios in which Powerline adapters are tested, these devices deliver pretty basic connection speeds. Moreover, different brands of adapters are equipped with varying connection speeds, all of which will perform differently based on a variety of factors.
Moreover, before you conclude on the Powerline speeds and performance with various devices, users must also factor in their Powerline adapter Ethernet connection. Because of the way adapters are set up to function, devices will only connect to the adapter and thus access the internet via Ethernet. This adds more complexity to the issue of speed and performance with regards to Powerline connections.
Functionality and convenience
Both Ethernet connections and Powerline adapters offer a solution for users seeking to extend connections to internet dead zones or outside your connections’ range. Ethernet networking allows users to utilize wireless and wired connections within the network to connect many devices on to the network. In fact this is quite different from Powerline networking where most of the time: one adapter will only connect one device to the connection. However, there are different adapter brands which offer connection to multiple devices via cable connection.
Powerline vs. Ethernet – A comparison review
Powerline- Overview and Key Features
A Powerline connection is a fascinating way different users can connect various devices when their already existent form of connection is insufficient. This connection requires the use of specialized devices which allow connection over your power lines: hence the name Powerline. Here are some of the features and requirements necessary to set up a successful Powerline connection.
Features
First, let us begin with HOW this type of connection works. As mentioned, said connection relies on the existent electrical wiring in your home to transfer data to the required device. This is achieved with Powerline adapters which are easy to set up and quite easy to use. Once connected, these adapters can connect wirelessly or via Ethernet Networking to serve you as needed. By allowing users to select between the Powerline Ethernet networking solution or an equally dependable wireless connection, Powerline connections are quite the versatile solution.
Similar to DSL, Powerline connections convey data in a separate electrical frequency, allowing the second adapter to pick up data/information problem free. In order to set up a Powerline network, there are various requirements to be met. Among this is an already existent internet connection. Often users with a router will use Powerline adapters to extend the range of their wireless connection to the internet dead zones around their space. Notably, every device requires its own Powerline adapter when setting up a PEN.
Luckily, these adapters do not require special software or hardware configurations. This makes the set up quite simple. In fact, in order to successfully set up a Powerline network/ connection, all you need is a minimum 2 Powerline adapters. One picks up the Ethernet protocol from your router and converts it to electrical impulse while the other reconverts it back to allow access using your various devices.
The speed of this connection is dependent on a variety of factors including the quality of wiring in your space. With a good enough wiring, anyone can set up a pretty efficient Powerline network with good enough speeds.
Broadband Powerline connections can be provided as a primary internet connection similar to DSL. This form of connection if developed to its potential will serve as a convenient way for ISPs to provide virtually anyone with electricity an internet connection. The tech transmits data and information over low-medium voltage power lines which are available everywhere.
In summary
If you are in the market for a networking solution that will provide a connection to devices outside your Wi-Fi range, then Powerline connections may be what you need. This is a versatile type of connection that is easy to set up and quite dependable as range extending devices or even networking solutions.
Advantages
- Cheap and easy installation will save you a lot of money
- Great solution for problematic wireless connection
- No wiring or configuration required to set up the network
Disadvantages
- Considerably slower especially for local file transfers but internet speeds often vary
Ethernet Overview and Key Features
Ethernet is a popular way many users are connected to the internet. In fact, it is the most popular type of LAN networking technology. This connection falls under the IEEE 802.3 standard which provides elaborate parameters of use for this form of networking technologies. Take a look at some of the features, properties and limitations of Ethernet.
Features
To most users, Ethernet is simply the cable you can use to connect your PC to various elements of your home/office network. While not entirely correct, this is somewhat true. This networking technology allows communication of devices within a network over the Ethernet cables. The goal here is to allow convenient handling or receiving of data packets within a network: more specifically, a LAN.
Some of the requirements for successful Ethernet networking apart from various cables include the NIC, network interface card, embedded in computers. This confers a unique ID to each device on the network. Notably, communication between devices using Ethernet is limited to no more than 10km.
Traditional Ethernet connections support speeds of up to 10mbps. However, this is dependent on many factors. Various Ethernet connections have varying transfer rates.
There are many types of Ethernet networks including switch Ethernet, fast Ethernet and Gigabit Ethernet. These categories are made based on speed of the connection. Fast Ethernet relies on fiber optic cables or twisted pair cables for transmission purposes. Using this type of Ethernet, users can transfer speeds of up to 100mbps. Gigabit Ethernet like the name suggests allows for transfer rates of up to 1000Mbps. This is the most recent and fastest type of Ethernet connection today.
Additionally, different Ethernet connections are sustained using different types of cables. These are designed to serve as connectors to systems and serves and are used for both commercial and domestic Ethernet connections. All 5 different types of cables are designed with varying capacities in terms data transfer speed and performance. Depending on the nature of data and information you intend to relay over these cables, the functionality and the Mbps rate needed: users can select between, Cat5, Cat5e, Cat6, Cat6a, and Cat7 Ethernet cables.
This connection supports various types of topologies and networks. Using a variety of cables and component arrangements, users can transfer or receive information and data within the network as needed. However, there are downsides to the Ethernet connections especially with regard to traffic prioritizing.
In summary
If you are in the market for a tried and true computer networking solution then Ethernet may be what you need. Ethernet is not only capable but quite versatile and will suit, home and even work space connections quite well.
Advantages
- Quite easy to and cheap to install
- Ethernet networks and connections are robust to noise
- Quality data transmission
- High speed connection
- Stable signal with reliable connection
Disadvantages
- Difficult network to troubleshoot
- Wired Ethernet connections are not easy to transport
Conclusion
Ethernet networking and Powerline networking solutions are both reliable ways to expand internet access within your respective spaces. Either solution allows users to connect onto existing connections with various means. While Ethernet offers a reliable connection over Ethernet cables, Powerline too is an easy and reliable way for users to gain said access.