Powerline Adapter vs. Wi-Fi extender – Improving your internet connection

Ever wondered what differences exist between Powerline Adapters and Wi-Fi extenders? You are not alone. Here you will find an in-depth review and helpful comparison for said options. Take a look.

When setting up a router, location is an important aspect.  Placed correctly, this router will make provisions for connection wherever you may be. However, this isn’t always the case. Most times, there is need secondary devices which allow more users to access the internet from “unreachable” ranges.

This is where technology like Powerline adapters and Wi-Fi extenders come in. Designed to improve accessibility, both technologies are a wonderful way to ensure users outside the connection range find a way in. There are many differences both in the design and workings of both these technologies. Here is Powerline Adapter vs. Wi-Fi extender with more.

What are the differences between Powerline Adapter vs. Wi-Fi extender?

	Powerline Adapter (Winner)	Wi-Fi extender
Transmission medium	Electric wiring	Wi-Fi rebroadcasting
Connection system	Can be physical or wireless	Wireless
Interference Performance	Susceptible to electric noise and signal degradation	Susceptible to signal degradation over broadcast
Speed of connection	Can reach even 1300Mbps	Depends of router signals
	View here	View here

 

Powerline Adapter vs. Wi-Fi extender – What are the main differences between the two?

Design and function

Since they are fundamentally different devices, of course Powerline Adapters and Extenders are bound to look and function different. Ideally, Powerline adapters have one role: to relay data and information in the form of electric impulses. This is converted back into a format which your devices can use. This operating principle is different from Wi-Fi extenders that not a corded system. In fact, they work by simply rebroadcasting Wi-Fi signals.

Notably, there are variations of Powerline adapters which allow them to transmit received data in a wireless functioning.

Performance

Notably, Powerline Adapters are more reliable in performance compared to Wi-Fi extender. Unlike adapters that pick up signals directly via wiring, extenders simply rebroadcast signals from your router. Due to interference and signal degradation throughout this process, the connection established over Wi-Fi extender internet is not the best.

None the less, Powerline networks are not interference free and are susceptible to electrical noise and signal interference throughout transmission.  In fact performance of connections over Powerline adapters is dependent on the quality of wiring in your space. Moreover, there is a difference in performance of either type of connections with multiple devices. Over Powerline networks, multiple connections are limited. Often one adapter is designed to connect one user to the network.

Speed

Theoretically speaking, Powerline adapters are meant to reach transfer speeds of up to 1300Mbps. This speed varies depending on the brand/type of adapter. Wi-Fi Extenders on the other hand are not limited and simply rebroadcast which ever signal they pick up.

Set up

Both the Powerline adapters and Wi-Fi extenders are quite easy to set up. This process is quite different for both. Powerline adapters connect to devices via cables and often require minimal if any configuration during set up. Extenders do not need said set up and need only be functional and within range of your existing router.  However, the Powerline adapters must be connected on the same circuit in order to pair and thus transmit data effectively. Moreover, these devices are limited by their performance over extension leads.

Convenience

Since Powerline adapters are fixed to the wall socket and connect via cable to devices as needed: it is difficult to move around with this kind of connection. Wi-Fi extenders maintain wireless connections and allow users to access the internet via WIFI.

Risk

Yes, use of Powerline adapters puts some of your devices at risk. Said adapters have the potential to cause harm by short-circuit to appliances and devices connected to your electric system, especially when connected via extension lead. Wi-Fi Extenders bear no such risk and are safe to use for range extension and connection purposes.

Powerline Adapter vs. Wi-Fi extender – A comparison review

Powerline Adapter Overview and Key Features

Powerline adapters are handy networking devices that allow users to expand or create a network using your existing electrical wiring. This is quite convenient not to mention easy to set up. Take a look at how these devices work, some of the universal features, capabilities and limitations.

Features

Most Power Line adapter devices are small box like devices with. They are the single most essential component for anyone looking to set up a Powerline network. In fact, without an Adapter, you cannot convert the signal from your router into one which can be conveyed over your wiring. When directly connected to the power line adapter, any device will receive the electric signal via Ethernet and effectively access the internet.

TIP: When you choose between different brands of Powerline Adapter, ensure the brand is fitted with a surge protector component which protects the connected devices. In fact, Powerline adapters with surge protectors allow users to plug in the device onto an extension when needed instead of directly into the wall socket.

Some of the other requirements of a Powerline adapter network set up aside from the adapter include an existing internet connection, a variety of cables and reasonable wiring. The idea is to plug the first adapter into your router and connect it to the wall socket. From another location outside the routers range, you can plug in adapter number two. Using the Ethernet connection mentioned above and simple configurations, users can now access internet. Many models come with power filters which help clean up any interference your data electrical signal experiences over the wiring.

Most of these devices often allow fast networking and users can stream shows and utilize the internet for viewing needs. However this system is not fault free. One of the biggest influential factors in the performance of transmission between adapters is the quality of electrical wiring in your home. Users with better wiring will experience better connection with higher speeds and data/information transfer rates. In fact, users are usually advised to stay away from this type of networking if their wiring isn’t the best.

In summary

Powerline adapters are a quick and easy fix for internet range issues and internet dead zones. Anyone with a router and some Ethernet cables can effective incorporate a Powerline adapter into their existing network for better connection access.

Advantages

• Immune from Wi-Fi interference
• Positioning is unimportant with Powerline adapters
• Work faster than other range extension technologies available
• Lead to no dead zones as signal is conveyed though the wiring

Disadvantages

• Susceptible to electrical interference and noise
• When used with extension cords, users experience transfer speed loses
• Costlier than counterpart

Wi-Fi extender Overview and Key Features

To put it quite simply, extenders are devices specifically designed to improve the coverage in your space. This is quite helpful considering that structural interference, other barriers and even router placement can mess with proper connection. By extending the routers base of operation and effectively expanding the area of connectivity, users in the same building can properly receive Wi-Fi signals. Here is a complete mini guide to Wi-Fi extenders and everything you need to know about them.

Features

Wi-Fi extenders function by rebroadcasting signals received from your router, these devices are a reasonable solution to any out of range connection problems you may have.

To clear up any confusion you may have about extenders, these connectivity improvement devices are quite different from other popular ones including boosters and repeaters. They mostly serve the same role and aren’t explicitly differentiated by manufactures. However, extenders are primarily connected to the router.

Like with said router, placement of the extender is everything. Since the device simply rebroadcasts what it has received, it must be place in a convenient enough position. Many brand makers advice users to place the device dead center of where your router is and where you intend to extend the connection to. Just ensure it receives a strong signal from the former.

Notably, there are two forms of extenders: Wireless range extenders and Wi-Fi Network extenders.

Speed loss on extenders is inevitable. Because they work by rebroadcasting the signals received, these devices can only retransmit the data packets they pick up. This incorporated latency in the network is the price users often have to pay with extenders. The solution is to use a dual band extender which greatly improves the potential reduction in bandwidth.

Another one of important issues with the installation of Wi-Fi extenders is the dramatic increase in the networks detectable range. For instance when you set up multiple extenders in a space which needs a strong and accessible signal from all points, then the range of the network might extend outside the space. This can be easily solved by setting up the right kind of security protocol. With the right kind of wireless security for your network, you can set up as many extenders, without worrying about outsiders hoping onto the network.

Advantages

• Simple installation
• Cheap way to improve connectivity in your home
• Can provide speed boosts in your network if installed and placed correctly
• Doesn’t lead to additional interference as it shares a channel with the main router

Disadvantages

• Are considerably slower in speeds as they typically suffer a minimum 50% signal loss
• If placed incorrectly, Wi-Fi extenders won’t do much for range improvement

Verdict: So which one is better, Powerline Adapters vs. Wi-Fi extender?

When faced with the choice: Powerline Adapters do a better job than Wi-Fi extenders in improving connections past your router range. Granted Powerline networking is not devoid of issues, it is a more stable connection which offers better data transfer speeds as needed.